SERMON 143: Public Diversions Denounced
An Introductory Comment

This was John Wesley's fifty-eighth written sermon and is something of a curiosity. Its setting is Epworth, where Wesley had arrived from Oxford on Thursday, August 31, 1732, on the eve of what was to have been an exciting 'public diversion' (i.e., a horse-race) on Friday―an event of intense interest in Epworth and vicinity. Instead, as we learn from Wesley's diary, there had been a disastrous fire which had caused extensive damage in the town. Wesley's diary suggests that the fire had started in the malt-kiln belonging to his own scapegrace brother-in-law, Richard Ellison. In any case, there was an Epworth tradition that this had been the breaking point in the marriage between Ellison and John's sister, Susanna. To John's dismay, the populace had blithely ignored so obvious a sign of God's wrath against them and had simply postponed their 'diversion' until the day following. John, however, saw it for the communal self-indulgence that it was and promptly vented his righteous indignation against the townfolk who showed up in church on Sunday, September 2. This, then, is the context for the large number of local allusions in the diatribe.

Clearly, however, this was not the sort of piece that Wesley would have wanted published under his name; that he even kept the sermon in his papers for so long sheds an interesting light on his self-image. After his death it was published, in a carelessly edited transcription, in the Arminian Magazine,1 without a title or number, but with an index reference to it as 'On the sinfulness of attending public diversions'. This may have been Benson's source for the title he gave to it in his edition of 1812 (viz., 'On Public Diversions'). As usual, Thomas Jackson followed him on this point.

The negative connotation here for the phrase, 'public diversions' had already become a standard reference for various kinds of popular spectacles: races, games, even fairs.2 Much later (1787), Wesley will return to the denunciation of diversions such as 'cudgellings, bear-baiting, cockfighting', characterizing them as 'these foul remains of Gothic barbarity―a reproach not only to all religion but even to human nature'.3
The holograph of this sermon is in the Colman Miscellany in the Methodist Archives, Manchester. It is written on sixteen duodecimo pages, with none of the usual indications of dates or provenance. We may suppose that it was an occasional sermon in the quite literal sense and not thereafter repeated. The present text is a transcription of the holograph.

3 Can two walk together, except they be agreed?
4 Will a lion roar in the forest, when he hath no prey? will a young lion cry out of his den, if he have taken nothing?
5 Can a bird fall in a snare upon the earth, where no gin is for him? shall one take up a snare from the earth, and have taken nothing at all?
6 Shall a trumpet be blown in the city, and the people not be afraid? shall there be evil in a city, and the LORD hath not done it?
7 Surely the Lord GOD will do nothing, but he revealeth his secret unto his servants the prophets.
8 The lion hath roared, who will not fear? the Lord GOD hath spoken, who can but prophesy?
9 Publish in the palaces at Ashdod, and in the palaces in the land of Egypt, and say, Assemble yourselves upon the mountains of Samaria, and behold the great tumults in the midst thereof, and the oppressed in the midst thereof.
10 For they know not to do right, saith the LORD, who store up violence and robbery in their palaces.
11 Therefore thus saith the Lord GOD; An adversary there shall be even round about the land; and he shall bring down thy strength from thee, and thy palaces shall be spoiled.

Public Diversions Denounced
Amos 3:6
Shall a trumpet be blown in the city, and the people not be afraid?
Shall there be evil in a city, and the Lord hath not done it?

'Tis well if there are not too many here who are too nearly concerned in these words of the prophet, the plain sense of which seems to be this: Are there any men in the world so stupid and senseless, so utterly void of common reason, so careless of their own and their neighbours' safety or destruction, as when an alarm of approaching judgments is given to show no signs of apprehension? To take no care of preventing them, but go on as securely as if no alarm had been given? Do not all men know that whatever evil befalls them, it befalls them by God's appointment?1 And that he appoints every evil of this life to warn men to avoid greater evils? That he sends these lighter marks of his anger to awaken men, that they may shun his heavier vengeance, and be timely advised, by feeling part of it, to change their ways, and not suffer his whole displeasure to arise?

I intend in speaking on this subject, first, to show in few words that there is no evil in any place which the Lord hath not done; secondly, to prove that every uncommon evil is the trumpet of God blown in that place, that the people may be afraid; and thirdly, to consider whether, after God had blown his trumpet in this place, we were duly afraid.

[I.] I am first to show in few words that there is no evil in any place which the Lord hath not done. No evil, that is, no affliction or calamity, whether of a public or of a private nature, whether it concerns only one or a few persons, or reaches to many or all of the place where it comes. Whatever circumstance occasions loss or pain to any man or number of men may in that respect be called an evil; and of such evils the prophet here speaks.

Of such evil we are to believe that it never is in any place but where the Lord hath done it. He hath done it either by his own immediate power, by the strength of his own right hand,2 or by commanding or suffering it to be done by those his servants that do his pleasure.3 For the Lord is King,4 be the people never [so] impatient; yea, the great King of all the earth.5 Whatsoever therefore is done in all the earth (sin only excepted) he doth it himself.6 The Lord God Omnipotent still reigneth,7 and all things are so subject unto him that his will must be done, whether we agree to it or no, as in heaven, so also upon earth.8 Not only his blessed angels, but all things, serve him in all places of his dominion:9 those wicked spirits that rule the darkness of this world, and those men who are like them, by constraint; the senseless and brute parts of the creation, by nature; and those men who are like God, by choice. But however it be, with or without their own choice, they all act in obedience to his will; and particularly when in his judgment he remembers mercy,10 and send[s] some evil that he may prevent greater. Then, at last, we are to acknowledge the hand of God, whatever instruments he makes use of. It makes no difference whether he executes his purpose by the powers of heaven or hell, or by the mistakes, carelessness, or malice of men. If a destroying angel march forth against a town or country, it is God that empowers him to destroy. If bad men distress one or more of their fellow-creatures, the ungodly is a sword of his. If fire, hail, wind, or storm be let loose upon the earth, yet they only fulfil his word.11 So certain is it that there is no evil in any place which the Lord has not done.

[II.] I am secondly to prove that every uncommon evil is the trumpet of God blown in that place where it comes, that the people may be afraid. Every private affliction is doubtless the voice of God, whereby he calls upon the afflicted to fly to him for succour. But of any extraordinary affliction, especially when many persons are concerned in it, we may not only say that in this God speaketh to us, but that the God of glory thundereth!12 This voice of the Lord is in power. This voice of God is in majesty.13 This demands the deepest attention of all to whom it comes. This loudly claims the most serious consideration, not only from those to whom it is peculiarly sent, but from all those that are round about them. This, like a voice from heaven, commands that all the people should be afraid, should tremble at the presence of God; that everyone should feel and show that religious fear which is both the beginning and the perfection of wisdom;14 that fear which should make them haste to do whatsoever the Lord their God commands them, and careful not to turn aside from it to the right hand or to the left.

'Tis needless to use many words to prove this, after what has been proved already. For if there be no evil in any place which the Lord hath not done, and if he doth not willingly send evil on any place, but only to warn them to avoid greater evils, then it is plain that wherever any evil is, it is the trumpet of God blown in that place, to the end that the people may be so afraid as not to continue in anything that displeases him. Then 'tis plain that in every such merciful evil God speaks to this effect: 'O that there were such an heart in this people that they would fear me, and keep my commandments always, that it might be well with them and their children for ever!'15

[III.] What signs we have shown of this wise and grateful fear I am thirdly to consider more at large. Let us consider first how God hath blown his trumpet in this place, and secondly whether we have been duly afraid.
[1.] First, let us consider how God hath blown his trumpet among us of this place. And that it may never be forgotten, it were much to be wished, not only that parents would tell their children, to the intent that their posterity might know it, and the children that are yet unborn, but also that it were written in our public register, for a standing memorial to all generations,16 that in the very week, on the very day, when that diversion which hath not had the least share in turning the Christian world upside down17 was to have been brought in hither also, such a fire broke out as neither we nor our forefathers had seen in this place,18 a fire which soon spread itself not over one only, but over several dwelling-houses; which so went forth in the fury of its strength that it soon prevailed over the weak resistance made against it, and left only so much standing of most of those buildings over which it prevailed as might serve to quicken our remembrance of it. Let it be told that those who came prepared for another prospect were entertained with that of devouring flames預 prospect which continued during the whole time of the intended diversion, and which was but too plainly to be seen, together with the fiery pillars of smoke which increased its horror, from the very place which had been pitched upon for the scene of this diversion.

This is the bare matter of fact. And even from this let anyone in whom is the spirit of man19 judge whether the trumpet of God hath not sufficiently sounded among us of this place! And doth this trumpet give an uncertain sound?20 How would you have God speak more plainly? Do you desire that the Lord should also thunder out of heaven, and give hailstones, with coals of fire?21 Nay, rather let us say, 'It is enough! Speak no more, Lord; for thy servants hear!'22 Those to whom thou hast most severely spoken are afraid, and do seek thee with their whole heart. They resolve not to prolong the time, but even now, by thy gracious assistance, to look well if there be any way of wickedness in them, and to turn their feet into the way everlasting;23 to renounce everything that is evil in thy sight,24 yea, the sins that do most easily beset them,25 and to use their whole diligence for the time to come to make their calling and election sure!26 Those to whom thou hast spoken by the misfortune of their neighbours are likewise afraid at thy tokens, and own it was thy mere goodness that they, too, and their substance, were not consumed. They likewise firmly purpose in themselves to make the true use of thy merciful warning; to labour more and more, day by day, to purge themselves from all sin, from every earthly affection, that they may be fit to stand in the presence of that God who is himself the most consuming fire!27

[2.] But have we indeed been thus duly afraid? This is now to be considered. And because we cannot see the hearts of others, let us form our judgment from their actions, which will be best done by a plain relation, of which everyone that hears it can easily tell whether it be true or false.

In the day following that on which the voice of God had so dreadfully commanded us to exchange our mirth for sadness, the diversion which that had broken off was as eagerly begun anew. Crowds of people flocked out of that very town where the destruction had been wrought the day before, and rushed by the place of desolation to the place of entertainment. Here you might see the ground covered with heaps of ruins, mingled with yet unquenched fire; a little way off as thick[ly] covered with horses and men, pressing on to see another new sight. On this side were the mourners bewailing the loss of their goods, and necessities of their families; on that the feasters delighting themselves with the sport they had gained. Surely such a mixture of mirth and sadness, of feasting and mourning, of laughing and weeping, hath not been seen from the day in which our forefathers first came up into this land, until yesterday!

[IV.] Such is the fear we have shown of the wrath of God! Thus have we been afraid after he had blown his trumpet among us! These are the signs we have given of our resolution to avoid whatever is displeasing in his sight! Hereby we have proved how we design to avoid that diversion in particular, which he has given us so terrible a reason to believe is far from being pleasing to him. Not that this is the only reason we have to believe so. Beside this last melancholy argument against it, we have so many others as any serious Christian would find it a hard task to answer. But I have only time to mention slightly a few of the consequences that were never yet separated from it.

Before I mention these, I desire it may be particularly observed that I do not say this diversion is sinful in itself. If anyone can find a race which has none of these consequences, let him go to it, in the name of God. Only till he finds one which does not give occasion to these or the like villainies, let him who nameth the name of Christ28 have a care of any way encouraging them.29

One thing more I would have observed, that it is so far from being uncharitable to warn well-meaning Christians of the tendency of these diversions, that the more clearly and strongly anyone represents it to them, the more charitable to them he is. This may be made plain by a very easy comparison. You see the wine when it sparkles in the cup,30 and are going to drink of it. I tell you there is poison in it, and therefore beg you to throw it away. You answer, 'The wine is harmless in itself.' I reply, Perhaps it is; but still, if it be mixed with what is not harmless, no one in his senses, if he knows it, will drink it; at least unless he could separate the good from the bad. If you add, 'It is not poison to me, though it be to others'; then I say, Throw it away, for thy brother's sake, lest thou embolden him to drink also.31 Why should thy strength occasion thy weak brother to perish, for whom Christ died?32 Now let anyone judge which is the uncharitable person: he who pleads against the wine or the diversion, for his brother; or he that pleads against the life of his brother, for the wine or the diversion.

[1.] All the doubt there can be is: 'Is there poison mixed with this diversion which is supposed to be harmless in itself?' To clear this up let us first observe the notorious lying that is always joined with it, the various kinds of over-reaching and cheating, the horrid curses and oaths that constantly accompany it, wherewith the name of our Lord God, blessed for ever, is blasphemed. When or where was this diversion ever known without these glorious consequences? Who was ever one day present at one of these entertainments without being himself a witness to some of these?33 And surely these alone, had we no other ill consequences to charge upon this diversion, are enough, till a way is found to purge it from them, to make both God and wise men abhor it.

[2.] But over and above these we charge it, secondly, with affording the fairest means to exercise and increase covetousness. This it does by the occasion it gives to all who please to lay wagers with one another, which commonly brings so strong a desire of possessing what is another's as will hardly cease when that one point is decided; but will be exceeding likely to leave such a thirst in the mind as not all the winning in the world will satisfy. And what amends can the trifling sport of a thousand people make for one soul thus ruined and corrupted? Therefore on this account, too, till a way is known to secure all that frequent it from this danger, well may this sport itself be an abomination to him who values one soul more than the whole world.34

[3.] May we not well fear that it is an abomination to him because of a third effect of it―because it is so apt to inflame those passions which he so earnestly commands us to quench? Because so many people are on this occasion so heated, as they never ought to be on any occasion? A man may indeed be angry, and not sin,35 but hardly, either upon such occasions, or in such a degree as those that are angry upon such occasions commonly are. This consequence, too, let him separate from this diversion, who would prevent its being displeasing to God.

[4.] Till this be done let no one ask, 'What hurt is there in a horse-race?'36 But [if] any should still ask that question, we can answer yet more particularly. Are you a young person that desire to go to it? Then 'tis likely you go either to see or to be seen; to admire other fine sights, or to be admired yourself. The hurt of this is, it is nourishing that friendship which is enmity with God;37 it is strengthening those affections which are already too strong―the lust of the eye and the pride of life.38 All such diversions as these are the noblest instruments the devil has to fill you with earthly, sensual, devilish39 passions; to make you of a light and trifling spirit, and, in a word, lovers of pleasure more than lovers of God.40 Are you who desire to go to it elder? And now less subject to these temptations? Take heed that your hearts deceive you not. But be it as you suppose, hath it not done you hurt enough if it has hindered any of you from partaking of the blessed sacrament? If by preventing either that serious examination or that private devotion which ye wisely use before you come to it, it has occasioned your neglecting to come to this holy table, and so not only disobeying a plain command of God, but likewise losing all those inestimable advantages which are there reached out to them that obey him? Are you a rich man that desire to go? Then you have probably given something towards it. That is, you have thrown away that seed which might have borne fruit unto eternity! You have sold for naught a part of [that] talent which might have purchased you another degree of glory in heaven! You have utterly lost what God himself, had you lent it to him, would richly have repaid you for. You have given to those who neither need, nor perhaps thank you for it, what if you had bestowed on your helpless brethren, your blessed Redeemer would have esteemed as done unto himself, and given you due thanks for it at the great day.41 Are you a poor man that have gone, or given anything, to this diversion? Then it has done you the most hurt of all. It has made you throw away, for an idle sport abroad, what your wife or family wanted at home. If so, you have denied the faith, and are so far worse than an infidel.42 But suppose it cost you no money: was it not hurt enough if it cost you any of your time? What had you to do to run after trifling diversions, when you ought to have been employed in honest labour? Surely if the rich think, God hath given them more time than they want (though 'tis well if they don't one day think otherwise) yet you have no temptation to fancy so: sufficient for your day is the work thereof.43

[V.] I have but a few words to add: and those I speak, not to them who are unwilling to hear, whose affections are set upon this world,44 and therefore their eyes are blinded by it; but I speak to them in whom is an understanding heart, and a discerning spirit; who, if they have formerly erred, are resolved by the grace of God now to return no more to the error of their ways; but for the time to come not only to avoid but also earnestly to oppose whatever is contrary to his faith or love. To these I say, Are ye young? So much the rather scorn all employments that are useless, but much more if they are sinful. For you are they whose wisdom and glory it is to remember your Creator in the days of your youth.45 Are ye elder? So much the rather bestow all the time which you can spare from the necessary business of this life in preparing yourself and those about you for their entrance into a better life. For your day is far spent, your night is at hand.46 Redeem therefore the little time you have left. Are ye rich? Then you have particular reason to labour that you may be rich in good works. For ye are they to whom much is given, not to throw away, but to use well and wisely; and of you much shall be required.47 Are ye poor? Then you have particular reason to work with your hands, that ye may provide for your own household. Nor when ye have done this have ye done all; for then ye are to labour that ye may have to give to him that needeth―not to him that needeth diversion, but to him that needeth the necessaries of nature, that needeth clothes to cover him, food to support his life, or a house where to lay his head.

What remains, but that we labour, one and all, young and old, rich and poor, to wipe off the past scandal from our town and people? First, by opposing to the utmost for the time to come, by word and deed, among our friends, and all we have to do with, this unhappy diversion which, if it be harmless in itself, has yet such terribly hurtful consequences; by doing all that in us lies,48 all we possibly can, to hinder its coming among us any more. And, secondly, by showing all the mercy we can to our afflicted neighbours, according as God hath prospered us; and by this timely relief of them, laying up for ourselves a good foundation against the day of necessity. Thirdly, by our constant attendance on God's public service and ever blessed sacrament, and our watchful, charitable, pious life.49 Thus giving the noblest proof before men and angels that though even after we were troubled we went wrong, yet upon more deeply considering how God had blown his trumpet among us, we were duly afraid! We then all said, with an awakened heart, 'Behold, the Lord our God hath showed us his glory and his greatness, and we have heard his voice out of the midst of the fire.'50 Now, therefore, while time is, let us put away far from us every accursed thing:51 'For if we hear this voice of the Lord our God any more, then we shall die.'52